The Playbook, Vol 6: The Value Pricing Myth: Why It Fails and What Actually Delivers Results

Ready to transform artificial intelligence from a buzzword into your personal revenue generator?

HubSpot’s groundbreaking guide "200+ AI-Powered Income Ideas" is your gateway to financial innovation in the digital age.

Inside you'll discover:

Download your guide today and unlock a future where artificial intelligence powers your success. Your next income stream is waiting.

Get Your Guide

Most agency pricing advice collapses the moment it meets a real sales conversation. This week's article takes on the myth that's been circulating for twenty years — that agencies should ditch hourly billing and charge purely on value — and explains why it fails for most founder-led shops. The alternative isn't a gimmick. It's a base-plus-performance model that keeps you paid for the work while giving you real skin in the game on outcomes. More importantly, it changes which clients you take — and that filter alone might be worth more than any pricing framework. Worth a read before your next proposal conversation.

Our latest published content.

The Agency Focus Podcast. Subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts.

Notes and observations from around the industry:

💸 Are You Busy or Actually Profitable? Agency Profit Benchmarks for 2026 (Move at Pace) Most agencies have scope creep — the question is whether you track it and charge for it. One agency owner discovered a single retainer client was getting £3,000 a year in free work through gradual scope expansion, and when he audited all retainer clients, the total unbilled work added up to £15,000 a year. The piece lays out gross margin, net margin, and utilization benchmarks by agency size and service type — with a clear-eyed look at why "we're doing fine" is the most dangerous sentence an agency owner can say without actually looking at the numbers.

🔁 Retention Is the New Growth: What the 2026 Agency Churn Data Is Telling Us (Focus Digital) Retainer-based agencies lose clients at roughly 18% annually versus 42% for project-based shops — and retainer clients stay nearly five years on average compared to just two years for project clients. The kicker: the first 90 days represent peak churn risk across all agency models, and agencies that set realistic KPIs during onboarding achieve 15–20 percentage points better retention than industry averages. Onboarding is your retention strategy.

🚧 Agency Growth in 2026 Isn't a Demand Problem — It's a Talent Problem (Method Recruiting) New business pipelines remain strong, client expectations continue to rise, and opportunities to expand services are everywhere — yet many agencies are finding themselves unable to fully capitalize on that demand. The root issue is increasingly clear: hiring bottlenecks. When you can't staff the work, existing teams absorb the workload, quality declines, and high-value clients become churn risks even when initial results were strong.

📐 The Scope Creep Math That's Quietly Killing Agency Margins (Beancount) 52% of all agency projects experience scope expansion, with 85% of those blowing through their budgets by an average of 27% — yet only 44% of organizations consistently use a formal change control process to stop the bleeding. The fix isn't a longer contract. It's a repeatable discovery process and a habit of treating every informal client request as a change order conversation.

🏆 What Separates 8-Figure Agencies from 7-Figure Ones (Predictable Profits) 8-figure agencies hold a 92% annual client retention rate compared to 78% for 7-figure agencies — and 73% of the top tier keep at least six months of operating expenses in reserve, versus just 31% of their smaller counterparts. The gap isn't about talent or market position. It's about financial discipline and structured account management showing up consistently, month after month.

Meet Marcus Ansell — better known as @TinnedFishReviews — a Nottinghamshire man who became a TikTok sensation by opening and taste-testing cans of fish from around the world. Usually sporting a fez and seated at his kitchen table like a man who has achieved complete inner peace, Marcus has built an empire on the simple act of saying things like "that's a lovely mackerel" directly into a camera. His most viral moment — six million views — involved eating Surströmming, a fermented Baltic herring so pungent he had to open the can underwater.

His catchphrase is "Let us decant the tin," which is somehow both deeply mundane and deeply noble. Co-starring in every episode are his wife Lucy, who films and edits everything and is credited only as "The Cameraman," and Arthur, a ten-year-old Collie/Great Pyrenees cross who has presumably smelled things no dog should ever have to smell. You can even buy t-shirts.

Find him on TikTok at @tinnedfishreviews and Instagram at @tinned_fish_reviews — and maybe send him a nice tin from your pantry. He's earned it.
Website: Tinned Fish Reviews